Love the look of an old fashioned, but not the taste of whiskey? Make it with brandy. A Brandy Old Fashioned keeps everything that makes the classic worth ordering (a little sweet, a little bitter, served over one big ice cube) and swaps in a spirit that's softer and fruitier.
WHat makes this different
Cherry juice and demerara syrup are where the depth comes from: the cherry adds fruit without candy sweetness, and the demerara brings a warm molasses note that regular simple syrup doesn't have.
A lot of old fashioneds end up tasting mostly like sugar or mostly like booze, and stirring this one over ice, then serving it on a single large cube, is what keeps it cold and balanced to the last sip.
This is the brown-liquor sipper I reach for when it gets cold out. It takes about 5 minutes, and it goes even faster if you make the demerara syrup ahead and keep it in the fridge.


What I Learned Making This Recipe
Confession: I don't like whiskey. Bourbon just isn't for me, but I still wanted a cozy brown-liquor drink to sip on a chilly evening. Brandy turned out to be the answer. It has the same warmth in the glass, with a rounder, fruitier flavor that plays really well with cherry and orange.
The cherry juice is where I did the most testing. I've made this with the juice from maraschino cherries, Bada Bing cherries, Luxardo cherries, and even bottled cherry juice. Every one of them works! My favorite is the Bada Bing juice, because it lands right in the middle: not too sweet, not too tart.
Jump to:
Ingredients
You only need a handful of ingredients to make this classic cocktail.

Ingredient Notes:
- Brandy. This is a spirit-forward drink, so the brandy is most of what you taste. Use one you'd happily sip on its own. My current favorite is Driftless Glen.
- Cherry juice. This is what makes it a cherry old fashioned instead of a plain one. It adds fruit, color, and a little sweetness. I usually pour it straight from the jar of cherries I'm garnishing with, since it's already open. Store-bought cherry juice works too.
- Demerara syrup. Demerara is a less refined cane sugar with a light molasses flavor, and that's what gives this drink its depth. My demerara syrup takes a few minutes to make at home. No time? A natural cane sugar cube plus a tablespoon of water works in its place. Regular simple syrup works in a pinch, but you'll lose some of that richness.
- Orange slice. It gets muddled with the syrup and then pulled out. Muddling presses the juice into the syrup, so you get bright orange flavor without bits of pulp floating in your drink. You can also just squeeze the orange slice in before stirring the drink if you don't want to muddle.
- Bitters. Think of bitters like salt in cooking. A couple of drops add flavor and keep the sweetness in check. I use cherry or orange bitters depending on my mood. Both work great.
- Cherries: Use the expensive cocktail cherries (Luxardo or Bada Bing are a few favorites) and save the inexpensive bright red cherries for your ice cream. It's worth it, I promise.
Instructions
Grab your a small bowl, a muddler and a mixing glass and you are ready to go!

- Step 1: Place the orange slice and the demerara syrup in a small bowl.

- Step 2: Muddle the orange to release the juices.

- Step 3: Pour the juice into a mixing glass.

- Step 4: Add the cherry juice, brandy and bitters to the mixing glass.

- Step 5: Add ice and stir vigorously to chill the drink.

- Step 6: Place a large ice cube in a glass and strain contents of the mixing glass over it. Garnish with a cherry and serve.
FAQs
Use a cherry juice you like. We have made it with cherry juice from Maraschino cherries, Bada Bing Cherries and Luxardo Cherries. You can even use cherry juice from a bottle. All taste great, but my preference is the Bada Bing cherry juice, which is not too sweet and not too tart. Try them all and find your favorite!
We use a citrus peeler to make the garnish for our cocktails. The oils the peel adds are the perfect finishing touch. Be sure you use a light hand to get the peel only and not much of the pith (white part) otherwise you will end up with a bitter taste in your drink.
Think of bitters as a seasoning, like salt in food. The dash of bitters adds flavor and balance to the cocktail. Just a few dashes go a long way so don't overuse.
A Wisconsin brandy old fashioned can be ordered sweet (made with Sprite soda), sour (made with Squirt soda), or dry (made with club soda). This Brandy Old fashioned recipe is closer to your traditional Old Fashioned but uses brandy instead of bourbon.

My best tips
- Stir it. Don't shake it. Shaking whips air into the drink and waters it down too much. Stirring chills it just as well and gives you a silky, velvety texture, which is exactly what you want in a drink this spirit-forward.
- Use one big ice cube. A large sphere or square cube melts more slowly than a handful of small ones, so your drink stays cold without turning watery halfway through.
- Splurge on the cherries. I know they're pricey. But the cherry is part of the flavor here, not just decoration, and it's the difference between a good brandy old fashioned and a great one.
- Peel the orange with a light hand. You want the colorful skin, not the white pith underneath, which is bitter and will come through in the drink. A citrus peeler makes this much easier than a paring knife.
- Don't overdo the bitters. A little goes a long way. Too much and the bitterness takes over the cherry and orange you worked to build.

More Great Cocktails
Nothing warms the insides like a great cocktail. Try this Añejo Tequila Old Fashioned or some of our other favorite drinks.
Made this? Loved it? Tell us everything!
Leave a quick star rating and comment below so we can trade tips and cheer each other on.
Who knows? Your twist might become someone else's new favorite!
Recipe

Brandy Old Fashioned
Ingredients
- ½ ounce demerara syrup
- 1 slice orange
- 1 ounce cherry juice
- 3 ounces brandy
- 2 drops cherry bitters, optional
- 2 Luxardo cherries, for garnish
- 1 orange peel, for garnish
Want to save this recipe?
By signing up, you'll join our email list and can unsubscribe at any time.
Instructions
- Add demerara syrup and orange wedge to a small bowl and muddle to combine.½ ounce demerara syrup, 1 slice orange
- Pour mixture into a cocktail mixing glass and discard the orange slice.
- Add cherry juice, brandy and bitters to mixing glass. Fill glass with ice and stir until well mixed.1 ounce cherry juice, 3 ounces brandy, 2 drops cherry bitters,
- Fill low ball glass with large sphere or square ice cube. Pour drink into prepared glass. Garnish with cherries and orange peel, if desired, and serve.2 Luxardo cherries,
Notes
- Demerara syrup: Make your own at home in a few minutes. Or use a natural cane sugar cube and 1 tablespoon of water. Simple syrup works in a pinch, with less depth.
- You can squeeze the orange in the glass instead of muddling if desired.
- Cherry juice: Juice from your jar of garnish cherries or store-bought both work.
- Bitters: Cherry or orange bitters, your choice.
- Cherries: Use good cocktail cherries, like Luxardo or Bada Bing.
- Stir, don't shake. Shaking adds air and over-dilutes a spirit-forward drink.
- Use one large ice cube so the drink stays cold without watering down.
- Peel the orange garnish with as little white pith as possible to avoid bitterness.
VIDEO
Nutrition
Nutrition info not guaranteed to be accurate.









Comments
No Comments