Cheesesteak Sandwiches

by | Oct 5, 2016 | All, Main Dishes

Feeding a crowd for the big game? These easy Cheesesteak Sandwiches will be the star of your menu.

Make your own Cheesesteak Sandwiches at home! This recipe for gooey Cheesesteak Sandwiches is perfect for a weeknight dinner or your next tailgating party.

Though I’ve never been to Philadelphia, I think the city of brotherly love would give me a nod of approval for this recipe for Cheesesteak Sandwiches. While not 100% authentic (everyone has an opinion on what makes a good cheesesteak), these sandwiches come pretty close to the real deal. And they make an excellent addition to your game day menu.

Hosting a bunch of hungry fans? Below are a few suggestions to ensure your Cheesesteak Sandwiches come together easily before game time.

  • Typically Cheesesteak Sandwiches are made with ribeye, but you don’t have to be a purist when it comes to the meat. I’ve made these successfully with ribeye, New York strip, top sirloin and skirt steak.
  • Part of what makes a Cheesesteak special are the super thin slices of meat, so pop your meat in the freezer before you slice it. Slightly frozen meat cuts much easier than cold or room temp meat.
  • You can prep a lot of this meal ahead of time. Do all of your slicing and chopping earlier in the day and store the fridge until you are ready to cook the sandwiches. The same goes for the garlic mayonnaise.
  • Place a cover on top of your pan while you melt the cheese over the meat and veggie mixture. It will melt more quickly and evenly.
  • Cheesesteaks are always messy. Embrace the imperfection.

Nothing says game day like Cheesesteak Sandwiches. Add this recipe for melty, gooey Cheesesteaks to your next tailgating menu.

Recommended Equipment


Straight on image of melted Cheesesteak Sandwiches on brown plate.

Yes, you can make excellent Cheesesteak Sandwiches at home. This recipe is perfect for game day!

Yield: 6-8

Cheesesteak Sandwiches

Cheesesteak Sandwiches

These easy Cheesesteak Sandwiches will be the star of your party!

Prep Time 25 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 40 minutes


  • 2 garlic cloves, finely minced
  • 2/3 cup mayonnaise
  • 1 - 2 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil
  • 1 1/2 pounds New York Strip steak, trimmed of excess fat and cut into VERY thin strips
  • 1 bell pepper (any color), thinly sliced
  • 1 medium onion, thinly sliced
  • 8 ounces mushrooms, thinly sliced
  • 8-10 thick slices of provolone cheese
  • 6 hoagie rolls
  • Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper


  1. Combine garlic and mayonnaise in a small bowl. Spread mayonnaise on hoagie rolls. Set aside.
  2. Heat 1 tablespoon olive oil in an extra large skillet over medium heat. Add bell pepper, onions and mushrooms and cook until veggies are tender. Remove veggies from pan. Add additional tablespoon of oil to pan if needed. Add meat to pan and cook until just a hint of pink remains. Stir veggies back into pan with meat and season with salt and pepper.
  3. Top meat and veggie mixture with cheese. Cover pan and allow cheese to melt for 2 minutes.
  4. When cheese is melted, scoop portions of cheesesteak onto hoagie rolls using a thin spatula.
  5. Serve immediately.


You may not use all of the garlic mayo. It will keep in the fridge for a few weeks, so slather it on a sandwich for lunch.

Nutrition Information:



Serving Size:


Amount Per Serving: Calories: 622Total Fat: 48gSaturated Fat: 17gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 27gCholesterol: 106mgSodium: 676mgCarbohydrates: 11gFiber: 1gSugar: 3gProtein: 35g

LOVE this recipe?

Follow us on Pinterest for more great recipes! Just click the little pin button at the top of the recipe card.

We're the creative juices behind Garnish with Lemon. In the past 8 years, millions of people have sipped & snacked on our recipes. Need easy, delicious party food and drinks for your next shindig? You’ve come to the right place.

Our Story

About Anna

Hi, I’m Anna, a former corporate communications nerd turned food fanatic. Turns out I like cooking for others A LOT more than explaining HR policies to them. C’mon over!


  1. Avatar

    I can’t even deal with how much I want one of these right now. I might just scrap tonight’s dinner plans altogether to get these in my life sooner!

    • Avatar

      I’m pretty sure it’s the ooey-gooey-melty-cheese. Gets me every time. 🙂

  2. Avatar

    Haha…it sounds like Bridget and I could be long lost sisters….when I’m really hungry, it’s not pretty. I don’t know how this happened, but I don’t think I’ve had a cheesesteak in almost 10 years….crazy! I’m swooning over all this melty cheese and peppers and mushrooms. This is getting adding to our dinner line up this week for sure!

    • Avatar

      I hope you enjoy it, Kelli! It’s great comfort food, especially as the evenings start to get cooler. My kids could give or take the mushrooms, but that just means more for me!

  3. Avatar

    I’ve always wanted to make cheesesteaks at home! What a great recipe! Thanks for sharing 🙂

  4. Avatar

    This is straight up #lunchhacks. So flavorful, simple and a delicious way to break the routine! The kids are gonna loooooove these!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *